{"basis":{"both":"the board's own minutes, matched to the same vote in the video","minutes":"the board's own minutes, as the town posted them — the official record","recording":"our reading of the meeting video, from a machine transcript — not an official record, and may be unreliable"},"board":"Finance Committee Public Hearing","by_basis":{"both":0,"minutes":17,"recording":0},"conflicts":0,"coverage":["17 votes at 1 meetings, 12 October 2023 to 12 October 2023 (FY2024-FY2024).","17 from the board's own minutes (1 of the 1 sets the town posted have been read), 0 of them matched to the recording; 0 from our minutes of a recording only.","A meeting with neither minutes read nor a recording we have written up has no votes here, which is not the same as no votes taken. Each fiscal year says how many such meetings the register knows of."],"fy_coverage":{"2024":{"meetings":1,"nothing":0,"ours_only":0,"recording_only_votes":0,"short":"Town minutes read for 1 of 1 meetings","status":"clerk","tag":"","text":"FY2024: 1 meeting on the town's calendar; 1 with the town's minutes read.","town_read":1,"town_unread":0,"town_unread_ours":0},"2025":{"meetings":3,"nothing":3,"ours_only":0,"recording_only_votes":0,"short":"Town minutes read for 0 of 3 meetings","status":"none","tag":"no town minutes read","text":"FY2025: 3 meetings on the town's calendar; 0 with the town's minutes read; 3 with no record we can use.","town_read":0,"town_unread":0,"town_unread_ours":0},"2026":{"meetings":2,"nothing":2,"ours_only":0,"recording_only_votes":0,"short":"Town minutes read for 0 of 2 meetings","status":"none","tag":"no town minutes read","text":"FY2026: 2 meetings on the town's calendar; 0 with the town's minutes read; 2 with no record we can use.","town_read":0,"town_unread":0,"town_unread_ours":0},"2027":{"meetings":1,"nothing":1,"ours_only":0,"recording_only_votes":0,"short":"Town minutes read for 0 of 1 meetings","status":"none","tag":"no town minutes read","text":"FY2027: 1 meeting on the town's calendar; 0 with the town's minutes read; 1 with no record we can use.","town_read":0,"town_unread":0,"town_unread_ours":0}},"fy_rule":"Fiscal years run 1 July to 30 June; a meeting is filed under the fiscal year it was held in.","fys":[2024],"generated_by":"scripts/build_vote_lists.py, from build_boards.py's join -- never edit by hand","grain":"One row per motion voted. Procedural votes (minutes, adjournment) are hidden unless asked for.","groups":[{"date":"2023-10-12","date_printed":true,"fy":2024,"fy_basis":"held in FY2024","id":"finance-committee-public-hearing-2023-10-12","label":"12 October 2023","links":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","label":"Town's minutes"},{"href":"https://www.lunenburgma.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Minutes/_10122023-432","label":"minutes on the town's site"}],"note":"","status":"","votes":[{"basis":"minutes","basis_note":"From the town's minutes of this meeting.","chips":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","text":"Town minutes ✓","tone":"ok"}],"conflict":"","id":"finance-committee-public-hearing-2023-10-12-0","links":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","label":"Town's minutes"},{"href":"https://www.lunenburgma.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Minutes/_10122023-432","label":"on the town's site"}],"moved_by":"Chris Menard","n":"","procedural":true,"quote":"motion to open the public hearing by chris menard, seconded by tom gray. all in favor","quote_kind":"verbatim","reason":"","result":"passed","result_label":"passed","result_text":"passed","seconded_by":"Tom Gray","title":"Open the public hearing."},{"basis":"minutes","basis_note":"From the town's minutes of this meeting.","chips":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","text":"Town minutes ✓","tone":"ok"}],"conflict":"","id":"finance-committee-public-hearing-2023-10-12-1","links":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","label":"Town's minutes"},{"href":"https://www.lunenburgma.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Minutes/_10122023-432","label":"on the town's site"}],"moved_by":"Chris Menard","n":"","procedural":false,"quote":"motion by chris menard to recommend approval for article a, seconded by tom gray to recommend approval. the vote was 4 to 1.","quote_kind":"verbatim","reason":"","result":"passed","result_label":"passed","result_text":"passed 4 to 1","seconded_by":"Tom Gray","title":"Recommend approval of Article A."},{"basis":"minutes","basis_note":"From the town's minutes of this meeting.","chips":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","text":"Town minutes ✓","tone":"ok"}],"conflict":"","id":"finance-committee-public-hearing-2023-10-12-2","links":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","label":"Town's minutes"},{"href":"https://www.lunenburgma.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Minutes/_10122023-432","label":"on the town's site"}],"moved_by":"Chris Menard","n":"","procedural":false,"quote":"motion by chris menard to recommend deferring to the special town meeting, seconded by tom gray. all in favor. a unanimous vote of 5 to 0.","quote_kind":"verbatim","reason":"","result":"passed","result_label":"passed","result_text":"passed 5 to 0","seconded_by":"Tom Gray","title":"Recommend deferring Article B to the special town meeting."},{"basis":"minutes","basis_note":"From the town's minutes of this meeting.","chips":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","text":"Town minutes ✓","tone":"ok"}],"conflict":"","id":"finance-committee-public-hearing-2023-10-12-3","links":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","label":"Town's minutes"},{"href":"https://www.lunenburgma.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Minutes/_10122023-432","label":"on the town's site"}],"moved_by":"Chris Menard","n":"","procedural":false,"quote":"motion by chris menard to defer article c, seconded by tom gray. all in favor. unanimous vote.","quote_kind":"verbatim","reason":"","result":"passed","result_label":"passed","result_text":"passed, unanimous (no count printed)","seconded_by":"Tom Gray","title":"Defer Article C."},{"basis":"minutes","basis_note":"From the town's minutes of this meeting.","chips":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","text":"Town minutes ✓","tone":"ok"}],"conflict":"","id":"finance-committee-public-hearing-2023-10-12-4","links":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","label":"Town's minutes"},{"href":"https://www.lunenburgma.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Minutes/_10122023-432","label":"on the town's site"}],"moved_by":"Chris Menard","n":"","procedural":false,"quote":"motion by chris menard to approve, seconded by tom gray. all in favor. unanimous vote.","quote_kind":"verbatim","reason":"","result":"passed","result_label":"passed","result_text":"passed, unanimous (no count printed)","seconded_by":"Tom Gray","title":"Approve Article D."},{"basis":"minutes","basis_note":"From the town's minutes of this meeting.","chips":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","text":"Town minutes ✓","tone":"ok"}],"conflict":"","id":"finance-committee-public-hearing-2023-10-12-5","links":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","label":"Town's minutes"},{"href":"https://www.lunenburgma.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Minutes/_10122023-432","label":"on the town's site"}],"moved_by":"Tom Gray","n":"","procedural":false,"quote":"motion by tom gray to recommend deferral, seconded by chris menard.","quote_kind":"verbatim","reason":"The record doesn't say how the vote went.","result":"not recorded","result_label":"The record doesn't say","result_text":"not stated","seconded_by":"Chris Menard","title":"Recommend deferral of Article E."},{"basis":"minutes","basis_note":"From the town's minutes of this meeting.","chips":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","text":"Town minutes ✓","tone":"ok"}],"conflict":"","id":"finance-committee-public-hearing-2023-10-12-6","links":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","label":"Town's minutes"},{"href":"https://www.lunenburgma.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Minutes/_10122023-432","label":"on the town's site"}],"moved_by":"","n":"","procedural":false,"quote":"a second motion to recommend approval of article e. a vote of 4 to 1.","quote_kind":"verbatim","reason":"","result":"passed","result_label":"passed","result_text":"passed 4 to 1","seconded_by":"","title":"Recommend approval of Article E (second motion)."},{"basis":"minutes","basis_note":"From the town's minutes of this meeting.","chips":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","text":"Town minutes ✓","tone":"ok"}],"conflict":"","id":"finance-committee-public-hearing-2023-10-12-7","links":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","label":"Town's minutes"},{"href":"https://www.lunenburgma.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Minutes/_10122023-432","label":"on the town's site"}],"moved_by":"Jay Simeone","n":"","procedural":false,"quote":"motion by jay simeone to recommend approval with reservation, seconded by jean russell.","quote_kind":"verbatim","reason":"The record doesn't say how the vote went.","result":"not recorded","result_label":"The record doesn't say","result_text":"not stated","seconded_by":"Jean Russell","title":"Recommend approval with reservation of Article F."},{"basis":"minutes","basis_note":"From the town's minutes of this meeting.","chips":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","text":"Town minutes ✓","tone":"ok"}],"conflict":"","id":"finance-committee-public-hearing-2023-10-12-8","links":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","label":"Town's minutes"},{"href":"https://www.lunenburgma.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Minutes/_10122023-432","label":"on the town's site"}],"moved_by":"","n":"","procedural":false,"quote":"a second motion to recommend approval. a vote of 4 to 1.","quote_kind":"verbatim","reason":"","result":"passed","result_label":"passed","result_text":"passed 4 to 1","seconded_by":"","title":"Recommend approval of Article F (second motion)."},{"basis":"minutes","basis_note":"From the town's minutes of this meeting.","chips":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","text":"Town minutes ✓","tone":"ok"}],"conflict":"","id":"finance-committee-public-hearing-2023-10-12-9","links":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","label":"Town's minutes"},{"href":"https://www.lunenburgma.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Minutes/_10122023-432","label":"on the town's site"}],"moved_by":"Jay Simeone","n":"","procedural":false,"quote":"motion by jay simeone to approve, seconded by chris minard. all in favor. unanimous vote.","quote_kind":"verbatim","reason":"","result":"passed","result_label":"passed","result_text":"passed, unanimous (no count printed)","seconded_by":"Chris Minard","title":"Approve Article G."},{"basis":"minutes","basis_note":"From the town's minutes of this meeting.","chips":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","text":"Town minutes ✓","tone":"ok"}],"conflict":"","id":"finance-committee-public-hearing-2023-10-12-10","links":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","label":"Town's minutes"},{"href":"https://www.lunenburgma.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Minutes/_10122023-432","label":"on the town's site"}],"moved_by":"Chris Menard","n":"","procedural":false,"quote":"motion by chris menard to recommend approval, seconded by jay simeone. all in favor. unanimous vote.","quote_kind":"verbatim","reason":"","result":"passed","result_label":"passed","result_text":"passed, unanimous (no count printed)","seconded_by":"Jay Simeone","title":"Recommend approval of Article H."},{"basis":"minutes","basis_note":"From the town's minutes of this meeting.","chips":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","text":"Town minutes ✓","tone":"ok"}],"conflict":"","id":"finance-committee-public-hearing-2023-10-12-11","links":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","label":"Town's minutes"},{"href":"https://www.lunenburgma.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Minutes/_10122023-432","label":"on the town's site"}],"moved_by":"Chris Menard","n":"","procedural":false,"quote":"motion by chris menard to recommend disapproval, seconded by tom gray. motion to recommend disapproval. recommending dis-approval 3 to 2.","quote_kind":"verbatim","reason":"","result":"passed","result_label":"passed","result_text":"passed 3 to 2","seconded_by":"Tom Gray","title":"Recommend disapproval of Article I."},{"basis":"minutes","basis_note":"From the town's minutes of this meeting.","chips":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","text":"Town minutes ✓","tone":"ok"}],"conflict":"","id":"finance-committee-public-hearing-2023-10-12-12","links":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","label":"Town's minutes"},{"href":"https://www.lunenburgma.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Minutes/_10122023-432","label":"on the town's site"}],"moved_by":"Chris Menard","n":"","procedural":false,"quote":"chris menard moves that we find no direct financial impact, seconded by tom gray. all in favor of finding no direct financial impact.","quote_kind":"verbatim","reason":"","result":"passed","result_label":"passed","result_text":"passed (all in favor, no count printed)","seconded_by":"Tom Gray","title":"Find no direct financial impact for Article J."},{"basis":"minutes","basis_note":"From the town's minutes of this meeting.","chips":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","text":"Town minutes ✓","tone":"ok"}],"conflict":"","id":"finance-committee-public-hearing-2023-10-12-13","links":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","label":"Town's minutes"},{"href":"https://www.lunenburgma.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Minutes/_10122023-432","label":"on the town's site"}],"moved_by":"Chris Menard","n":"","procedural":false,"quote":"motion by chris menard to recommend approval, seconded by jean russell. all in favor. unanimous vote.","quote_kind":"verbatim","reason":"","result":"passed","result_label":"passed","result_text":"passed, unanimous (no count printed)","seconded_by":"Jean Russell","title":"Recommend approval of Article K."},{"basis":"minutes","basis_note":"From the town's minutes of this meeting.","chips":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","text":"Town minutes ✓","tone":"ok"}],"conflict":"","id":"finance-committee-public-hearing-2023-10-12-14","links":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","label":"Town's minutes"},{"href":"https://www.lunenburgma.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Minutes/_10122023-432","label":"on the town's site"}],"moved_by":"Jay Simeone","n":"","procedural":false,"quote":"articles l, m, n recommended by jay simeone to find no direct financial impact on the october 4th draft for article l, article m, article n, seconded by tom gray.","quote_kind":"verbatim","reason":"","result":"passed","result_label":"passed","result_text":"passed, unanimous (no count printed)","seconded_by":"Tom Gray","title":"Find no direct financial impact for Articles L, M and N on the October 4th draft."},{"basis":"minutes","basis_note":"From the town's minutes of this meeting.","chips":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","text":"Town minutes ✓","tone":"ok"}],"conflict":"","id":"finance-committee-public-hearing-2023-10-12-15","links":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","label":"Town's minutes"},{"href":"https://www.lunenburgma.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Minutes/_10122023-432","label":"on the town's site"}],"moved_by":"Chris Menard","n":"","procedural":true,"quote":"motion to close public hearing by chris menard, seconded by tom gray at 9:21 pm.","quote_kind":"verbatim","reason":"The record doesn't say how the vote went.","result":"not recorded","result_label":"The record doesn't say","result_text":"not stated","seconded_by":"Tom Gray","title":"Close the public hearing at 9:21 PM."},{"basis":"minutes","basis_note":"From the town's minutes of this meeting.","chips":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","text":"Town minutes ✓","tone":"ok"}],"conflict":"","id":"finance-committee-public-hearing-2023-10-12-16","links":[{"href":"/docs/meetings/finance-committee-public-hearing/2023-10-12-minutes-432.pdf","label":"Town's minutes"},{"href":"https://www.lunenburgma.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Minutes/_10122023-432","label":"on the town's site"}],"moved_by":"Jay Simeone","n":"","procedural":true,"quote":"motion to adjourn by jay simeone, seconded by chris menard.","quote_kind":"verbatim","reason":"The record doesn't say how the vote went.","result":"not recorded","result_label":"The record doesn't say","result_text":"not stated","seconded_by":"Chris Menard","title":"Adjourn the meeting."}]}],"kind":"board","meetings":1,"quote_rule":"A quote is the minutes' own words, checked verbatim when they were read. A vote from the recording only is a motion as heard by a language model from captions, never a quote.","results":[{"key":"passed","label":"passed","n":13},{"key":"not recorded","label":"The record doesn't say","n":4}],"slug":"finance-committee-public-hearing","standfirst":"Every motion the Finance Committee Public Hearing voted on that a record we hold shows, newest first.","title":"Every Finance Committee Public Hearing vote","votes":17}